Keith Worsley Professor, Department of
Statistics and the College
University of Chicago
Department of Statistics
5734 S. University Avenue
Eckhart Hall, Room 106
Chicago, IL 60637 USA
Phone: Leave message with 773.702.8335.
Fax: 773-702-9810
Research Interests
The geometry of random images in astrophysics
and brain mapping
The geometry in the title is not
the geometry of lines and angles but the geometry
of topology, shape and knots. For example, galaxies
are not distributed randomly in the universe,
but they tend to form clusters, or sometimes strings,
or even sheets of high galaxy density. How can
this be handled statistically? The Euler characteristic
(EC) of the set of high density regions has been
used to measure the topology of such shapes; it
counts the number of connected components of the
set, minus the number of `holes,' plus the number
of `hollows'. Despite its complex definition,
the exact expectation of the EC can be found for
some simple models, so that observed EC can be
compared with expected EC to check the model.
A similar problem arises in functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI), where the EC is used
to detect local increases in brain activity due
to an external stimulus. Recent work has extended
these ideas to manifolds so that we can detect
changes in brain shape via structure masking,
surface extraction, and 3D deformation fields.
Finally, we look at some curious random fields
whose excursion sets are strings, and we show
using the Siefert representation that these strings
can be knotted.
Detecting changes in brain shape, scale and
connectivity via the geometry of random fields
Three types of
data are now available to test for changes in
brain shape: 3D binary masks, 2D triangulated
surfaces, and trivariate 3D vector displacement
data from the non-linear deformations required
to align the structure with an atlas standard.
We use the Euler characteristic of the excursion
set of a random field as a tool to test for localised
shape changes. We extend these ideas to scale
space, where the scale of the smoothing kernel
is added as an extra dimension to the random field.
Extending this further still, we look at fields
of correlations between all pairs of voxels, which
can be used to assess brain connectivity. Shape
data is highly non-isotropic, that is, the effective
smoothness is not constant across the image, so
the usual random field theory does not apply.
We propose a solution that warps the data to isotropy
using local multidimensional scaling. We then
show that the subsequent corrections to the random
field theory can be done without actually doing
the warping - a result guaranteed in part by the
famous Nash Embedding Theorem. This has recently
been formalized by Jonathan Taylor who has extended
Robert Adler's random field theory to arbitrary
manifolds.
Recent advances in random field theory
Since Robert Adler's 1981 book on the geometry
of random fields, the many successful applications
to astrophysics and brain mapping in the last
10 years have provoked a flurry of new theoretical
work. We trace the history of this development
over the last 20 years, touching on: Robert Adler's
early work on the expected EC of excursion sets;
David Siegmund and Jiayang Sun's approach to finding
the P-value of the maximum using Weyl's tube formula;
Kuriki and Takemura's link between the two; Naiman
and Wynn's improved Bonferroni inequalities; Robert
Adler's proof that the expected EC really does
approximate the P-value of the maximum; Jonathan
Taylor's extensions to manifolds; the role of
the Nash Embedding Theorem; and Jonathan Taylor's
remarkable and unexpected Gaussian Kinematic Fundamental
Formula for finding EC densities.
The statistical analysis of fMRI data
Our proposed method for the statistical analysis
of fMRI data seeks a compromise between validity,
generality, simplicity and execution speed. The
method is based on linear models with local AR(p)
errors. The AR(p) model is fitted via the Yule-Walker
equations with a simple bias correction that is
similar to the first step in the Fisher scoring
algorithm for finding ReML estimates. The resulting
effects are then combined across runs in the same
session, across sessions in the same subject,
and across subjects within a population by a simple
mixed effects model. The model is fitted by ReML
using the EM algorithm after re-parameterization
to reduce bias, at the expense of negative variance
components. The residual degrees of freedom are
boosted using a form of pooling by spatial smoothing.
Activation is detected using Bonferroni, False
Discovery Rate, and non-isotropic random field
methods for local maxima and spatial extent. We
briefly look at an alternative method based on
conjunctions. Finally, we use a simple method
to estimate and make inference about the delay
of the hemodynamic response function at every
voxel. We conclude with some suggestions for the
optimal design of fMRI experiments.